The Glory of Ken Russell’s “The Devils” – a Film For Our Time

“At the time that I made The Devils, I was a devout Catholic, and secure in my faith. I knew I wasn’t making a pornographic film. Far from it. In fact, the movie had the blessing of the Jesuits. Even to this day it is still taught at Loyola University in Chicago as a good Catholic movie. For myself, although I am not a political creature, I always viewed The Devils as my one political film. To me, it was about brainwashing, about the state taking over. It is based entirely upon John Whiting’s play The Devils, and upon the writings of Aldous Huxley. Huxley was by no means a sensationalist – he was a historian of some note.

According to Huxley’s The Devils of Loudun, in 17th-century France there was a crisis caused by the desire of Cardinal Richelieu, the king, and their cohorts to pull down the walls of the city of Loudun. This would render Loudun defenseless, so it wouldn’t be a threat to the crown or the church. The same had already happened to other cities, with the result that they subsequently had to concede to every indignity and injustice imposed upon them. The people of the town felt that as long as the walls of Loudun were standing, then they could defend themselves.”

–Ken Russell, 1995.

All stills are screenshots from The Devils provided by fancaps.net.

The Devils, a controversial film that came out in 1971, is an expression now 55 years old, yet it is perfectly tuned for the moment in which we find ourselves today.

The movie details a period beginning around 1629 and culminating in 1634 when a religious insanity overtook a group of nuns – and eventually the entire French town of Loudun. Not only an amazing document of dramatic creativity, technical nuance, and not a little bit of performative “chewing the scenery,” the film is also perfect for America right now. It speaks to the exact trends and issues going on in the West generally, but in America specifically.

Anchored by incredible performances from Vanessa Redgrave and Oliver Reed (as well as a wonderful cast of supporting characters), the film explores religious insanity and the ways in which the lust for power and political expedience can often be couched in the language of faith. It also demonstrates the ways in which religious thinking is magical thinking, as well as how the imaginary world of “devils” and “evil” can displace (and even destroy) practical systems of governance and social fabric.

With symmetry and visually visceral themes that must have inspired Alejandro Jodorowsky‘s The Holy Mountain (1973) and Santa Sangre (1989) respectively, The Devils is filled with imagery and language that highlights the tension between social complexity and aesthetic contrast. There’s a sense in which the entire structure of the movie is about the play between a complex and ever-reinterpreted social contract and the black-and-white thinking that dominates the performance of dogma. When politics gets connected to those fraught poles, something has to break. We’ve seen it over and over again… and that’s one of the reasons the Founding Fathers of America tried to forever separate church and state. They knew the lessons of history in ways we don’t seem to recall today. Indeed, at almost the same time as “devils” were found in Loudun they were present on our own continent, to just as bitter ends. Some instincts die hard.

This movie is not for the faint of heart. People who have experienced violence – sexual or otherwise – or any kind of physical trauma, should probably steer clear or view the visuals available online (such as fancaps.net) to see if they want to subject themselves to the movie itself. Interestingly, in spite of its intense imagery, perhaps the most violent events are kept off screen or slightly hidden by a hand, fabric, or structure.

Oliver Reed’s performance as Father Urbain Grandier is, in part, a reputational rehabilitation. In the same way that Mel Gibson valorized William Wallace, stylizing him as primarily an inspiration for “FREEDOM!!” Ken Russell does something similar for Grandier in his film. Certainly, Urbain Grandier was a complex and flawed individual. In the movie we go from despising him, to almost respecting him, to practically cheering for him at the end. In this narrative arc, there’s an inversion taking place between the two main characters of Urbain and Mother Superior Jeanne des Anges. On the one hand is the sensual, secularized priest who is motivated by his own sexual and political power. On the other hand is a nun who has devoted herself to the service to God but who is hounded by her own sexuality and by the deformity of her own body. These two characters form the crux of the narrative. The film creates a connection between her deformity and malformed lust for Grandier and his transformation from womanizer to dedicated husband.

The monumental quality of the filmmaking here calls to mind the grand epics of Hollywood past and future. One might see how Nolan wishes he could craft a work of historical referent of similar power. Or, conversely, how Spielberg answered the challenge with his own takes on history, psycho-drama, and technical wizardry.

For me, the aesthetic choices – the whiteness, the blackness, the curvilinear and angular choices – are what sets Russell’s attempt apart. The sheer massiveness of the Loudun walls contrasts with the cramped interiority of some of the nunnery cells. There’s a strange geometry at play – in the cathedral and Grandier’s chambers as well as in the structure of the nuns cloister.

I won’t spoil the story for you. It would be easy to post images of the debauchery, the church-and-state-sanctioned torture, or the epically-scaled destruction. But you have to choose to see it yourself. It’s beautiful, strange, challenging, and hard… but it is also deeply human. This is a film about who we are. It is intimately connected to how we’ve tried to understand ourselves. And it’s a critique and an indictment. Even today we allow ourselves to be divided over assumption, over dogma, over instinct and blind lust. Even though we know better, and have created systems to help us know better, we fail to follow the “better angels of our nature.”

One of my favorite scenes was Cardinal Richelieu being wheeled through the church archives by attendants lol

One final thought: contemporary consciousness theory has impact here. There are thinkers in this area (pioneered by Julian Jaynes) who believe that people in fairly recent centuries did not consider all of the things they thought, dreamed, or imagined as coming from their own mind. Jaynes in particular thought that before circa 1000 CE, most people “were not conscious of their own thoughts… and that stories about gods speaking to people originated from people hearing their own inner voices and mistaking them for the voices of external deities telling them what to do.”

If we entertain this idea, then allow it to dovetail with the known power of religious thinking – not to mention social and familial pressures – it is easy to see how magical thinking, mental illness, and religious fervor could coalesce into the kinds of events we see in the historical background of The Devils of Loudun or The Salem Witch Trials. In so many ways we are captive to the adaptive biological constraints that both gave us the modern world and trap us in tribal and fearful thinking.

Ken Russell’s The Devils gives us a vision of that. I encourage you to watch it and read more about the situation that inspired it. We are living through the exact same kind of thing right now. People are allowing magical dream-logic to determine how they will conduct their lives. People are imagining fantasies about other humans rather than thinking through the implications of their social, political, and relational choices.

It’s time for us to grow up as a species. There are no devils, only our own flawed assumptions speaking to us. Can we coordinate with each other to triangulate truth or will we continue to silo ourselves, breaking off good will and the joy we could share?

A Question of Balance

Dedicated to George, who introduced me to A Question of Balance in the mid-80s.

~

It is interesting what stays with us from the early years of life. Seemingly banal or incidental elements can mysteriously transmogrify into certain means of grace. And grace is always strange.

It follows then that these grace-laden elements might be loaded with weirdness or saturated with some slow-acting agent of unforeseen change. Of course, that’s part of why the grace that has touched my life is different from the grace that’s touched yours. So often what is tremendously meaningful to one heart seems trivial, shallow, or just plain boring to others. Sometimes what changes me forever would do nothing to the person right next to me.

Nowhere is that fact more apparent than in the music with which we fill our lives. The bands we become attached to, what songs move us, or which albums are soundtracks to our personal transformations are usually radically different for everyone. Everyone seems to have a different constellation of sounds, a different set of aural landmarks. When we do find someone who shares our deep connection to a piece of music there’s instant rapport. When we encounter those who seem unable to grasp the importance of our historical tracklist we can find ourselves incensed.

With that preface let me say that A Question of Balance is one of the major musical touchstones of my life. Released in 1970 by The Moody Blues, Question is, for me, one of the most significant works of art to which I’ve been exposed. It is strange. It is bombastic. It is epic. It is philosophical. It risks existential engagement. It tries to take on everything. It is critical of our default positions. It asks us if this world we’ve made is really what we want. Before I knew much of anything about the wider world, I was connecting with the introspective spiritual and societal quandaries the band was dealing with in this classic concept album.

url

If you are aren’t familiar with the record and want to experience it you can listen to the whole thing here.

Hearing Question as a child was one of the things that would, by the time I was 13 or 14 years old, initiate in me a long-term investigation into the nature of meaning and experience. The sorts of questions the record poses set me off on what has been a lifetime of learning and intellectual exploration. It was a means of grace to me simply because it stimulated me to contemplate those bigger existential concerns that so often get drowned in the machinations of everyday life. Question, along with a number of other factors, created an ongoing state of contemplation in me that helped me avoid many of the pitfalls of adolescence.

There are a thousand things I could say about this record. Like how those jangling guitars at the opening of the album can instantly return me to George’s old golden/mustard/brown Dodge and the smell of propane. Like how the album’s assertions went with Chris and me on our adventures northward so many times. Like how its words were a reminder of the feeling of home as I ventured out across the country in my twenties. The sounds and questions and arguments of A Question of Balance accompanied me on many late nights in the studio, on the road, in contemplation, in worry, in joy.

I could spend time exploring any of those avenues, but there’s one aspect of Question that has really reverberated within me over the years. A major theme of the record amounts to acknowledging the relational consciousness that transcends obsessive, hyper-individualism. This one thread, running throughout the entire record but focused in one particular track, was definitely a seed that found good soil in me.

Below you can read the major content of that single track. Called The Balance (click here to listen to it), it is the last song on the album and is comprised mostly of Mike Pinder’s spoken word recitation of a poem co-written by Graeme Edge and Ray Thomas.

After he had journeyed,

And his feet were sore,

And he was tired…

He came upon an orange grove.

 

And he rested.

 

And he lay in the cool.

And while he rested

He took to himself an orange, and tasted it.

 

And it was good.

 

And he felt the earth to his spine

And he asked…

 

And he saw the tree above him…

And the stars… and the veins in the leaf… and the light… and the balance

 

And he saw

Magnificent Perfection.

Whereon, he thought of himself in balance –

And he knew he was.

~

And he thought of those he angered, for he was not a violent man.

And he thought of those he hurt, for he was not a cruel man.

And he thought of those he frightened, for he was not an evil man.

 

And he understood…

He understood himself.

 

Upon this, he saw

That when he was of anger

Or knew hurt

Or felt fear

It was because he was not understanding

 

And he learned Compassion.

And with his eye of Compassion,

He saw his enemies like unto himself.

And he learned Love.

Then, he was answered.

The tired wayfarer of the poem gains perspective from the Common Grace embedded in the world around him. He relishes the coolness of the orange grove, the simple pleasure of tasting the orange, and – suddenly – the glorious awareness of the Great Order that is before him and beyond him, yet is also permeating him. As he pays attention to the tree, the stars, the leaf, and the light his growing perspective and awareness coalesce into a unifying understanding. The traveler experiences what could be seen as the state of consciousness called Savikalpa Samadhi (something which has more recently been termed The Overview Effect) and he is fundamentally changed in his relationship to other human beings.

Suddenly he’s not obsessing about his rugged individualism any more; he’s thinking of others:

And he thought of those he angered…

And he thought of those he hurt…

And he thought of those he frightened…

Thinking of others – believing that they actually exist and are valuable. Considering others – imagining how your words, actions, or attitudes impact them. Revolutionary ideas, right? But it doesn’t stop there. The journeyman turns his new-found perspective on himself and starts to see that being enslaved to anger and hurt and fear displayed his lack of understanding. In fact, it showed his inability to understand at all apart from a revelation from beyond himself. Realizing this, and sensing his necessary reciprocity with the rest of humanity, our traveler learns compassion. That is, in giving up his self-determined privileged position he can no longer feel superior to or more valuable than those around him. He can, in acknowledging and respecting their value, live out a higher value in himself.

All of this can be passed off as trite, sure. It can be dismissed as sentimental, unrealistic, or melodramatic. It can be ignored as the cheesy platitudes of a bunch of hippies. Sure. But it can also be seen as aligned with the heritage of the great faith and wisdom traditions that have been passed down to us, traditions that certainly inspired the band while creating this album.

I know it’s all more complex than this. I can see how The Balance can come off simplistic and hokey. I know that real change and real meaning require more than a singular experience, more than surge of feeling… but there is something important here, something worth declaring, worth believing. Rejecting sentiments such as those contained in Question seems like such a shallowly postmodern thing to do.  What have cynicism and petty ideological divides gotten us? I guess I’d rather stand in awe with the kitschy hippies than smirk in conceit with those who would disdain words – however sentimental – supporting basic human dignity and value.

~

Post Script:

My experience of A Question of Balance is a demonstration of Joseph Kupfer’s ideas about the inherent moral component of experiencing art. You can read more about this concept here.

The album is certainly worth buying and grappling with. Purchase it at iTunes or Amazon.